Home
Breast & breast cancer
Breast cancer Benign breast lesions Prophylactic mastectomy
Breast reconstruction
All techniques Implant reconstruction Latissimus dorsi flap DIEP flap (abdomen) Gracilis flap (thigh) Fat grafting (lipofilling) Flat closure Intimate surgery
Benign gynaecological surgery
Uterus Ovaries and tubes Cervix Vulva and vagina
Gynaecological cancers
Cervical cancer Ovarian cancer Uterine cancer Vulvar cancer Borderline tumours Articles About
Request a callback Book on Doctolib →
A female radiologist in a white coat reads mammograms (MLO and CC views) on a monitor, in a dim radiology reading room.
Breast biopsy

Imaging-biopsy discordance: why operate despite a reassuring biopsy

The report of your biopsy mentions a benign lesion, and yet you are being offered a repeat biopsy or an operation. This situation has a name: discordance between imaging and biopsy. It means that the result obtained under the microscope does not satisfactorily explain the image seen on the mammogram, the ultrasound or the MRI. It does not mean that there is a cancer. It means that the diagnosis is not yet certain, and that it needs to be completed.

Dr Jérémie Zeitoun
In brief

Imaging-biopsy discordance means that the biopsy result does not explain the image. It affects 1.2 to 5.3% of breast biopsies, according to a systematic review published in 2026. Dr Jérémie Zeitoun explains why a repeat biopsy or an excision is then proposed, after review by the multidisciplinary team meeting.

This article draws in particular on the SENORIF 2025-2026 guidelines.

Your biopsy is reassuring, but you are being told about discordance or surgery?

Bring the biopsy report and the images. Dr Jérémie Zeitoun, cancer and breast surgeon, sees patients at the practice at 241 rue du Faubourg Saint-Honoré (Paris 8th) and at Clinique Hartmann (Neuilly-sur-Seine). Surgery takes place at Clinique Hartmann.

An online consultation is possible. You can book an appointment on Doctolib or request a callback from the secretariat.

RADIOLOGIC-PATHOLOGIC CONCORDANCE

What radiologic-pathologic concordance means

A female pathologist in a white coat, with a laboratory microscope and a tray of glass slides in front of her.

A biopsy result is never read on its own. It is read alongside the image that led to the biopsy.

The radiologist first describes the abnormality and classifies it according to its level of suspicion. An image classified ACR 4 or ACR 5 leads to a sample being taken. This classification does not name a disease: it says how suspicious the image is.

Five categories

The sample is then analysed by the pathologist, the doctor who examines tissue under the microscope. The pathology report classifies the result into five categories:

Cate­goryWhat it meansWhat usually follows
B1Normal or non-diag­nostic tissueCheck that the target was sampled; most often, a repeat biopsy if the image is suspicious
B2Benign lesion, for example a fibroadenomaIf the result is con­cordant, generally no surgery; if it is dis­cordant, a repeat biopsy or excision
B3Lesion of uncer­tain malig­nant potentialExcision in most cases, by surgery or by vacuum-assisted biopsy depending on the lesion
B4Suspicious lesion, without certaintyRepeat biopsy or diag­nostic excision; no treatment surgery on this result alone
B5Cancer, in situ or invasiveWork-up and treatment discussed at the multi­disciplinary team meeting

Comparing the two

One last step remains, and it is essential: comparing the two. The radiologist who performed the biopsy reviews the result, compares it with the images and states whether this result explains what was seen.

The radiologist records this in the report, with a proposal for what comes next. If in doubt, the radiologist discusses it with the pathologist.

Concordant or discordant

A result is concordant when it explains the image. An oval, regular mass, classified ACR 4A, which corresponds to a fibroadenoma under the microscope: the image and the result tell the same story.

A result is discordant when it does not explain it. The image was highly suspicious, or the sample did not reach its target, and the word “benign” is not enough to reassure. In this case, the result cannot be accepted as the final diagnosis.

THE LIMITS OF A BIOPSY

Why a biopsy may not be enough

A biopsy analyses a few fragments of the lesion, not the whole lesion. It therefore avoids surgery in the great majority of cases, but it may not represent the whole lesion.

Several reasons explain why a sample may not reach its target or may not fully represent it:

  • a small, deep or mobile lesion, which moves away from the needle;
  • dense breasts, in which the lesion is hard to make out;
  • a heterogeneous lesion, partly benign and partly suspicious;
  • an extensive cluster of microcalcifications, of which only part is sampled;
  • a lesion visible only on MRI, for which there is no simple way of checking, during the procedure, that the right area has been sampled.

What the figures say

A systematic review published in 2026 brought together twenty-three studies on this subject. In series covering all biopsies, a discordant benign result concerns 1.2 to 5.3% of biopsies.

When these lesions are re-sampled or removed, a cancer is found in proportions that vary widely from one study to another. In the most representative series, this rate is around 20 to 40%. These are invasive cancers and ductal carcinomas in situ.

Most discordances are therefore benign, but the risk of cancer is too high to settle for surveillance.

THE DECISION

The decision at the multidisciplinary team meeting

Multidisciplinary meeting: doctors, some in white coats, others in everyday clothes, around a table; a female radiologist points to mammograms (MLO and CC views) on a large screen.

The choice between surveillance, a repeat biopsy and surgery is discussed at the multidisciplinary team meeting. This meeting brings together, in particular, the radiologist, the pathologist and the surgeon.

Each brings their own reading of the file: the radiologist presents the images and how the sampling went, the pathologist describes what was seen under the microscope, the surgeon assesses what an operation would add and how it would be performed. The opinion given is then explained to you in consultation, and the decision is made with you.

Dr Zeitoun reviews the imaging and the reports, examines you and explains why a check is being proposed, and in what form.

If a repeat biopsy is indicated, it is performed by the radiologist. Appointment on Doctolib, online consultation or request a callback from the secretariat.

THE OPERATION

The operation: a diagnostic procedure

A surgical biopsy for discordance is a diagnostic procedure. It does not presume a cancer, and it is not a mastectomy: only the area in question is removed, with a small margin of tissue around it.

A female radiologist prepares a localisation hook-wire beside a patient, next to a mammography unit.

Preoperative localisation

The lesion often cannot be felt. On the day of the operation or a few days before, the radiologist places a marker in the area to be removed, under ultrasound or mammography. This preoperative localisation is performed under local anaesthetic.

It may be a hookwire, a fine wire whose tip is anchored in the lesion, or a magnetic clip, depending on the case. The small metal clip placed during the biopsy often serves as the target.

In the operating room, a masked team, with an anaesthetist at the head, prepares an excision before any incision; the patient’s face is uncovered.

In the operating theatre

The surgeon removes the localised area, placing the incision as discreetly as possible, for example around the areola when the position of the lesion allows. The operation is performed under general anaesthetic, most often as day surgery, with discharge the same day.

During the operation, the removed specimen is X-rayed. This X-ray checks that the marker, the clip and, where applicable, the cluster of microcalcifications are indeed in the specimen, before it goes to the laboratory.

Dr Zeitoun practises in Sector 2 (non-OPTAM) and charges fees above the French Social Security rate for all consultations and procedures. Most international patients are not covered by French Social Security. A detailed quote is given during the consultation, before any procedure. If you are covered, the Assurance Maladie reimburses on the basis of the Social Security rate, and your health insurance may cover all or part of the additional fees, depending on your policy.

After the operation

Recovery is usually straightforward: some discomfort or moderate pain, relieved by standard painkillers, and sometimes a bruise that fades. See preparing for your operation and recovery after surgery.

The whole surgical specimen is analysed. The result is reviewed in consultation and, if needed, at the multidisciplinary team meeting.

FOLLOW-UP

Follow-up after a biopsy or an operation

When a biopsy result is benign and concordant, no operation is generally needed. Depending on the nature of the lesion, the radiologist may propose follow-up imaging at 4-6 months before considering a return to routine follow-up.

After a surgical biopsy showing a benign lesion, follow-up resumes according to your age and your risk factors. After an at-risk lesion, such as atypical ductal hyperplasia, closer surveillance of both breasts is proposed.

Report without delay any new lump, any change in the skin or the nipple, or any bloody discharge.

Frequently asked questions

My biopsy is benign: why talk about surgery?

Because the result does not explain the image. When the image is highly suspicious or the target was not reached, a benign result is not enough to rule out a lesion. A repeat biopsy or an excision makes it possible to obtain a certain diagnosis.

Does discordance mean that I have cancer?

No. In most cases, the lesion turns out to be benign. But a cancer is found in a significant proportion of cases, which justifies completing the diagnosis.

Who decides that there is discordance?

The radiologist who performed the biopsy compares the pathologist’s result with the images. The file is then discussed at the multidisciplinary team meeting.

Can the biopsy be repeated rather than operating?

Often, yes. A vacuum-assisted biopsy under stereotactic or ultrasound guidance, performed by the radiologist, may be enough when its result clearly explains the image. Surgery is proposed when the discordance is clear-cut or when a repeat biopsy would not provide certainty. See breast biopsy.

How does the surgeon find a lesion that cannot be felt?

Thanks to a preoperative localisation placed by the radiologist, a hookwire or a magnetic clip. The specimen is X-rayed during the operation to check that the area has indeed been removed.

Is a B3 lesion a cancer?

No. It is a lesion of uncertain malignant potential. Excision is most often proposed, by surgery or by vacuum-assisted biopsy depending on the type of lesion. See atypical ductal hyperplasia.

When is follow-up imaging done after a benign biopsy?

When the result is benign and concordant, the radiologist may propose, depending on the nature of the lesion, follow-up imaging at 4-6 months before considering a return to routine follow-up.

Is the operation performed under general anaesthetic?

Yes. The surgical biopsy is performed under general anaesthetic, most often as day surgery, with discharge the same day. See recovery after surgery.

If the operation shows a cancer, is another operation needed?

Not always. The surgical biopsy has often already removed the lesion. A second operation may be needed to widen the safety margins or to look for the sentinel lymph node in the case of an invasive cancer.

What are Dr Zeitoun’s fees?

Dr Zeitoun practises in Sector 2 (non-OPTAM) and charges fees above the French Social Security rate for all consultations and procedures. Most international patients are not covered by French Social Security. A detailed quote is given during the consultation, before any procedure. If you are covered, the Assurance Maladie reimburses on the basis of the Social Security rate, and your health insurance may cover all or part of the additional fees, depending on your policy.

Can I ask for a second opinion?

Yes, on the images as well as on the biopsy report. See second opinion for breast cancer.

Further reading

Neighbouring pages, to go further.

FREN
ONLINE CONSULTATIONVideo consultation · by appointment