Home
Breast & breast cancer
Breast cancer Benign breast lesions Prophylactic mastectomy
Breast reconstruction
All techniques Implant reconstruction Latissimus dorsi flap DIEP flap (abdomen) Gracilis flap (thigh) Fat grafting (lipofilling) Flat closure Intimate surgery
Benign gynaecological surgery
Uterus Ovaries and tubes Cervix Vulva and vagina
Gynaecological cancers
Cervical cancer Ovarian cancer Uterine cancer Vulvar cancer Borderline tumours Articles About
Request a callback Book on Doctolib →
In the consulting room, the doctor, in a white coat behind his desk, smiles as he welcomes a patient seated opposite him.
Breast

Lumpectomy for a benign breast lesion: when and how?

Your breast biopsy report concludes that the lesion is benign, or that it is a so-called “at-risk” lesion. Yet you are being advised to have it removed. This operation is called a lumpectomy: the surgeon removes the lesion and keeps the breast. This article explains why it is sometimes proposed for a benign lesion, for which lesions, how it is prepared and what happens afterwards.

Dr Jérémie Zeitoun
In brief

A lumpectomy for a benign breast lesion removes the area of the lesion. It mainly concerns benign at-risk (B3) lesions, to check that there is no cancer next to them. It is also discussed in case of radio-histological discordance. Benign lesions are monitored. A fibroadenoma may be removed in four situations. By Dr Jérémie Zeitoun, breast surgeon in Paris.

This article draws in particular on the SENORIF 2025-2026 guidelines.

The doctor, smiling, listens to a patient asking her questions across the desk, a folder in front of him.

Has your biopsy report concluded that the lesion is benign or “at-risk”, and has an excision been proposed?

Come with this document and your imaging examinations: at the consultation, Dr Jérémie Zeitoun goes through your file with you and explains why the operation is proposed, or why surveillance may be considered.

THE REASONS

Why operate on a benign at-risk lesion?

Two reasons lead to removing a benign at-risk lesion: checking that there is no cancerous lesion next to it, or a radio-histological discordance, when the biopsy result does not match the images.

Surgery or vacuum-assisted biopsy

In case of radio-histological discordance, two options are possible: a second biopsy or surgery. For B3 lesions, either a vacuum-assisted excision, performed by the radiologist, or surgery is proposed. For atypical ductal hyperplasia and phyllodes tumour, surgery remains preferred.

The vacuum-assisted biopsy is performed by the radiologist, under local anaesthetic, with a larger needle that suctions the lesion out little by little. No theatre, no scar (see papilloma: surgery or surveillance). These options are discussed at the multidisciplinary team meeting.

Fibroadenoma: benign, but sometimes removed

A fibroadenoma is entirely benign. The default approach is ultrasound monitoring (first check-up at 4 months then annual). Excision is offered in four situations:

  • doubt on biopsy (phyllodes, atypia, not formally concordant result);
  • significant growth over two successive check-ups;
  • bothersome symptoms — persistent pain, palpable discomfort, deformation of the breast;
  • informed choice of the patient who prefers not to think about it any more, after full information.
Breast ultrasound: the radiologist, seen from behind at three-quarters, places the probe on the patient's breast and watches the screen.

Concordance between imaging and biopsy

When the report arrives, the radiologist checks that what the microscope says matches what was seen on the image. This is called concordance.

The radiologist performs the breast ultrasound, the mammogram and the biopsy. The surgeon comes in afterwards, with the radiologist’s reports.

BEFORE THE PROCEDURE

Before the procedure

Before the procedure, three steps follow one another: the consultation with the surgeon, the discussion of your file between doctors, then, if the lesion cannot be felt, its localisation by the radiologist.

The consultation

Dr Zeitoun examines you, then goes through the imaging and biopsy reports with you. He explains the management of your lesion.

When surveillance is possible

Before any surveillance, a surgical or radiological excision is often required, discussed case by case at the multidisciplinary team meeting. The conditions for surveillance alone are detailed on the pages on atypical ductal hyperplasia and lobular carcinoma in situ.

Multidisciplinary team meeting: five doctors around a table review patient files together.

The team meeting

The multidisciplinary team meeting brings together doctors from several specialties around your file. Each case is discussed there.

The choice between surveillance, repeat biopsy and surgery is discussed at the multidisciplinary team meeting. This meeting brings together, in particular, the radiologist, the pathologist and the surgeon.

In the radiology room, the radiologist prepares to mark the area to be removed; the patient lies calmly under a sheet.

Localising a lesion that cannot be felt

The lesion generally cannot be felt. The radiologist therefore places a marker before the procedure: this is preoperative localisation. It guides the surgeon during the operation, to the lesion.

The hookwire is a thin metal wire, placed under local anaesthetic on the morning of the operation or the day before, which shows the surgeon where to operate. The magnetic clip can be placed several weeks before surgery.

The aim of surgery: to remove in one single block the localisation marker (hookwire or magnetic clip) and the surrounding lesion. An X-ray is performed at the end of the operation to check that everything has been removed.

MARGINS

Margins: why they rarely matter here

The margins are the edges of the specimen: we look at whether abnormal cells touch them.

In cancer surgery, the question arises differently: see positive margins after lumpectomy.

Atypical lesions

An atypical ductal hyperplasia is never re-excised, even in case of involved margins or residual atypia on the specimen.

For radial scar, most often, the analysis confirms a radial scar, with or without atypia. In that case, there is usually no reason to operate again, even if the lesion touches the margins.

Lobular carcinoma in situ

Classic form: if the margins are involved, there is no re-excision. Pleomorphic or florid form: if the margins are involved, a further excision is recommended.

Phyllodes tumour

Phyllodes tumour is classified into three grades: benign, borderline, malignant. The principle is simple: remove the entire tumour en bloc, with a cuff of healthy tissue all around. The minimum margin recommended is ≥ 1 mm for benign phyllodes and ≥ 10 mm for borderline and malignant phyllodes.

For a benign phyllodes tumour with an involved margin, there is no further operation: surveillance by clinical examination and ultrasound is organised for 3 years. For a borderline or malignant phyllodes tumour, if the histological analysis shows insufficient margins for the given grade, a re-excision is proposed.

SURVEILLANCE

Imaging surveillance

After the procedure, surveillance depends on the lesion removed. It relies on clinical examination and imaging, at set intervals.

Atypical ductal hyperplasia

A first mammo-ultrasound control at 6 months post-operatively (± magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) if the initial diagnosis was made or completed by MRI), then annual surveillance for at least 10 years by bilateral mammography + ultrasound (± MRI depending on context).

Lobular carcinoma in situ

A clinical breast examination every year; a two-view mammogram every year for 10 years, then every 2 years.

Radial scar

Surveillance by ultrasound and/or by mammogram is then planned for ten years, at intervals agreed with Dr Zeitoun.

Phyllodes tumour

  • Benign. If a margin is involved: clinical examination and ultrasound for 3 years.
  • Borderline. Clinical examination every 6 months for 2 years, then yearly up to 5 years. Annual mammography and ultrasound for 5 years.
  • Malignant. Same schedule, with surveillance chest imaging.

Fibroadenoma

Fibroadenoma removed: systematic ultrasound check-up at 6 months, then return to standard screening rhythm according to age and risk factors. Fibroadenoma not removed: first check-up at 4 months then annual.

The doctor hands a document to a smiling patient across the desk.

Would you like a surgical opinion before deciding whether or not to have your lesion removed?

Dr Zeitoun goes over the biopsy result and the imaging with you, then tells you what is appropriate in your case, operation or follow-up.

Frequently asked questions

My biopsy says “benign”: why am I being offered an operation?

Because a benign lesion may be at risk: what we sampled is benign, but that sample is not enough to answer for the whole area. The operation checks that there is no cancerous lesion next to it, or responds to a radio-histological discordance. A fibroadenoma, entirely benign, may also be removed in four situations.

Is a lumpectomy for a benign lesion the same operation as for a cancer?

The principle is the same: removing an area of the breast and keeping the rest. The rules differ: no sentinel lymph node; no radiotherapy, except for pleomorphic lobular carcinoma in situ or lobular carcinoma in situ with necrosis and for borderline or malignant phyllodes tumour; and for an at-risk lesion such as atypical ductal hyperplasia, margins that are not clear do not lead to a second operation.

Can the lesion be monitored instead of removed?

Yes for a benign lesion: a fibroadenoma is monitored by default, a hamartoma is simply monitored. For an at-risk lesion, before any surveillance, a surgical or radiological excision is often required, discussed case by case at the multidisciplinary team meeting.

Can a vacuum-assisted biopsy replace surgery?

For B3 lesions, either a vacuum-assisted excision, performed by the radiologist, or surgery is proposed. For atypical ductal hyperplasia and phyllodes tumour, surgery remains preferred. These options are discussed at the multidisciplinary team meeting.

What happens if the analysis finally finds a cancer?

Across all B3 lesions, 10 to 30% of cancers are found on the surgical specimen. Management then becomes that of a breast cancer. Dr Zeitoun explains it to you at the consultation, with the report in hand.

If the margins are not clear, do I need further surgery?

For atypical ductal hyperplasia, classic lobular carcinoma in situ, a radial scar or a benign phyllodes tumour, no; for a benign phyllodes tumour, surveillance by clinical examination and ultrasound is organised for 3 years. For pleomorphic or florid lobular carcinoma in situ, a further excision is recommended. For a borderline or malignant phyllodes tumour, the minimum margin is ≥ 10 mm; if it is insufficient for the given grade, a re-excision is proposed.

What scar will there be after the operation?

It depends on the size of the lesion and its location. In most cases, a single simple scar is enough, periareolar (around the areola) if the lesion is close to the nipple; when the volume of tissue removed is significant relative to breast size, the breast is reshaped by oncoplastic surgery. For a fibroadenoma, the incision is inframammary or axillary whenever the topography allows.

What follow-up is there after the operation?

It depends on the lesion. Atypical ductal hyperplasia: first control at 6 months, then annual surveillance for at least 10 years. Benign phyllodes tumour with an involved margin: clinical examination and ultrasound for 3 years; borderline or malignant phyllodes tumour: over 5 years; fibroadenoma removed: ultrasound check-up at 6 months; fibroadenoma not operated on: first check-up at 4 months then annual.

What are Dr Zeitoun’s fees?

Dr Zeitoun practises in Sector 2 (non-OPTAM) and charges fees above the French Social Security rate for all consultations and procedures. Most international patients are not covered by French Social Security. A detailed quote is given during the consultation, before any procedure. If you are covered, the Assurance Maladie reimburses on the basis of the Social Security rate, and your health insurance may cover all or part of the additional fees, depending on your policy.

Further reading

Three signs that lead to a consultation.

FREN
ONLINE CONSULTATIONVideo consultation · by appointment